Contact Books Training Speaking Coaching Assessments Blog
ABOUT
Our Purpose Testimonials More Content About Us

16-Building The Next Generation of SMEs

Season #3

🎙️ Podcast Show Notes

Building The Next Generation of SMEs

Episode Summary

In this episode, Jody Holland and the team explore a growing challenge in today’s workplace: the decline—or transformation—of critical thinking in the age of AI. As tools like ChatGPT, Google, and automation become increasingly embedded in daily work, organizations face a new reality: how to intentionally develop the next generation of Subject Matter Experts (SMEs).

This conversation unpacks the balance between leveraging technology and maintaining human intelligence, while offering practical strategies for developing expertise, transferring knowledge, and strengthening critical thinking across generations.

🔑 Key Topics & Insights

1. The Evolution of Thinking in the Digital Age * The shift from “I’ll remember it” → “I’ll Google it” → “AI will generate it” * Technology has not eliminated thinking—it has changed how thinking is applied * The risk: outsourcing discernment and judgment “When we let something else do our thinking for us, we lose our capacity to evaluate.”

2. What Is Critical Thinking—Really? * Not just intelligence, but interrogation of information * Asking: * Where did this come from?

What does it mean?

Is it true?

Requires:

  • Curiosity
  • Discernment
  • Willingness to challenge assumptions “It’s the questions behind the question that define critical thinking.”

3. The SME Gap: Knowing a Lot vs. Knowing Deeply

Modern workforce trend:  Many people know a little about a lot

Fewer people know a lot about a little

True SMEs are built through:

  • Focus
  • Depth
  • Repetition

Ownership of a domain Practical Insight:

  • Clearly define responsibilities
  • Prioritize mastery in a specific area
  • Reduce distraction from non-essential tasks

4. AI as a Tool—Not a Replacement

AI should function as a thought partner, not a substitute

  • Over-reliance leads to:
    • Shallow thinking
    • Reduced problem-solving ability

Weak communication skills “Everything is a tool… You still have to embrace your humanness to solve problems.”

5. The Breakdown in Foundational Thinking Skills

  • Entry-level thinking skills are being skipped:
    • Writing emails
    • Structuring responses
    • Understanding audience needs

Leaders are seeing:

  • Poor communication clarity
  • Over-reliance on generated responses

Key Principle:

You must learn the fundamentals before automating them

6. Communication as a Core Differentiator

High-demand skill: effective communication

Requires:

  • Adapting to the audience
  • Understanding context

Delivering clarity Example Framework:

  • Executive communication:
    • 1 sentence summary
    • 3 bullet points
    • Details if needed

7. Knowledge Transfer Is Broken (and How to Fix It) The Problem:

Older generations often:

  • Don’t share knowledge
  • Assume others won’t listen

Younger generations:

  • Don’t know what to ask
  • The Solution:
    • Curiosity-driven mentorship
      • Ask better questions:
        • "What did you learn?”
        • “What mistakes shaped your success?”
        • “There’s no cheat code—only lessons learned through experience.”

8. The Power of Self-Documentation

  • High performers create their own systems:
  • Process guides
  • Step-by-step documentation
  • Personal knowledge bases

Benefits:

  • Reinforces learning
  • Enables scalability
  • Creates institutional knowledge

9. The Danger of “Absolute Truth”

  • Critical thinking stops when questioning stops
  • Continuous inquiry leads to:
    • Deeper understanding
    • Better decisions
    • Stronger expertise

“If you think something is the absolute truth, you stop asking questions.”

10. The Three Pillars of Building Future SMEs

  • Foundational Thinking Skills
    • Teach basics before tools
    • Build from the “bottom rung”
  • Mentorship & Knowledge Transfer
  • Structured mentorship programs
  • Reverse mentoring through questioning
  • Resilience & Growth Mindset
    • Embrace failure as part of learning
    • Focus on the journey, not just outcomes

“Fall in love with the journey, not the destination.”

đź’¬ Powerful Quotes

  • “Critical thinking is the ability to let go of bias and be open to truth wherever it leads.”
  • “Curiosity is the foundation of critical thinking.”
  • “Paintbrushes don’t paint pictures—people do.”
  • “The most important skills aren’t hard skills—they’re human skills.”

đź“Ś Key Takeaways

  • AI is accelerating work—but human thinking remains the competitive advantage
  • SMEs are developed through depth, not just exposure
  • Critical thinking is fueled by curiosity and questioning
  • Organizations must intentionally design mentorship and knowledge transfer
  • Communication and discernment are becoming top-tier leadership skills
  • The future belongs to those who can combine technology with human insight

🚀 Action Steps for Leaders

  1. Audit your team’s thinking skills
    1. Are they analyzing or just generating responses?
  2. Implement structured mentorship
    1. Pair experience with curiosity
    2. Train foundational communication
      1. Especially written clarity
  3. Encourage self-documentation
  4. Build internal playbooks
  5. Create “think-first” culture norms
    1. Solve before searching

🎯 Final Thought: In a world increasingly driven by automation, the organizations that win will not be those with the best tools—but those who develop the best thinkers.

Follow me on social media!

Facebook: @thejodyholland

Instagram: @thejodyholland

Leadership Courses https://www.jodyholland.com/training