3 Reasons Performance Reviews Don’t Work

engagement leadership performance management performance reviews Oct 13, 2022
3 Reasons Performance Reviews Don’t Work

As the generations change, so does the approach to managing performance in the workplace. A couple of generations ago, performance was managed in an annual conversation and written evaluation. The annual performance review proved to provide very little developmental value over and over again, but we kept doing it. Out of habit, or duty, or lack of a better idea, sitting down for an hour once a year and telling people what was wrong with them stayed the trend. Knowing that these did little to nothing to improve performance, what was it that made them ineffective?

  1. Performance reviews are not done in a timely fashion. I remember in a previous job hearing one of my coworkers complain that they had to endure the verbal flogging of their manager for leaving the door unlocked when they had worked a 13-hour day… 11 months earlier! Far too many managers simply save up all their complaints to spew them on their people during the review. If you do not have monthly 1:1 conversations with your direct reports, they will not change the things that matter when they matter.

If managers have taken the time to interact with, coach, develop, and care about their people, they will have an amazing annual review. This means that feedback is required within a short window of time when it is needed, with the review being tied directly to measurable aspects of their performance and success, and the review is focused on conditioning the best behaviors for employee success. Reviews can be a bit daunting unless you have a game plan going in.

Stay connected with news and updates!

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.
Don't worry, your information will not be shared.

We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.